
What? No I'm fine. Just stretching.
Melvira and I went to a screening of “The Last Exorcism” the other night and I should have known when the man himself, Eli Roth, came onscreen to convey a personal message to the audience (plead for positive reviews), it wasn’t going to end well.
For those of you who don’t know the story, here it is right quick:
Son of an evangelical preacher man who grew up teaching the faith, but has none of his own, sets out to make a documentary with thoughtful female boom operator and wise-cracking camera man in order to expose the practice of exorcism as a lie. He visits backwoods family whose “possessed” daughter Nell, Dad, and brother Caleb are clearly not right. Nell could double as yogi master if she didn’t have a penchant for killing livestock and trying to fillet her brother’s face. Brother is a sleepy and disturbed red head. Dad recently lost wife and believes in home schooling.
Sounds pretty awesome, right?
What started out as a solid and fun story eventually devolved into multiple horror cliches and a completely disjointed finale. Both Mel and I felt like we had seen two different movies by the time the credits rolled. It’s as if the writers were possessed (see what I did there?) by the demons of movie marketing and convinced that although an audience would sit through about an hour of fairly original storytelling, they’d be damned if they were going to allow for a unique ending. But velvet capes and pentagrams, that could work.
I’ve probably ruined too much already, but just in case please be warned: SPOILERS AHEAD!
As always I’ll start with the most important part first. Should you see it? We try to answer that via some gchat bullshittin’:
“The Last Exorcism”: Dig It or Bury It?
Melvira: That’s tough, but bury it, I wouldn’t watch it again. It sucks ‘cuz I really like it. It’s like the “Sybil” of horror movies.
Scara: Bury it, but I feel the same way. It’s a cautionary tale for filmmakers. Loved the first hour so I can’t totally dismiss it, but I was so disappointed that I can’t bring myself to tell people to watch it in the theaters.
Ginger Kids = Always Scary
Melvira: I was really pleased with the beginning -pleasantly surprised.
Scara: The pacing was great, there was a nice storytelling quality about the plot.
Melvira: Yeah, it had a nice mix of humor and suspense. There were a few really good “oh shit!” moments.
Scara: Casting was perfect – Ashley Bell, who played Nell, was so subtle in her creepiness. She went back and forth from completely vulnerable to terrifying with just a little smile and a shift in her gaze.
Melvira: She was great, and I thought Patrick Fabian was hilarious.
Scara: It reminded me a bit of the way girls are cast in Japanese horror: can’t help being evil.
Melvira: Yeah, I can see that, especially some of the camera shots they did, seemed very in that vain of creepy/innocent.
Scara: Yeah and Caleb too – Do you know that’s the actor’s name? It’s like he was born to play backwoods brother. Ginger kids. Always scary.
Melvira: His name is Caleb Landry Jones.
Scara: Yeah, it’s so perfect. The other thing I appreciated about the first 2/3 of the film is that the horror came from the threat rather than the actual act. All building of suspense. It made the “Blair Witch” shaky cam, which I typically can’t stand, tolerable.
Melvira: Well, I have to say the one thing I did like about the cam, the only thing, is that when she got ahold of the camera, it was intense when it would shut off and then come back on. You didn’t know what to expect.
Um … When Did We Start Watching an Episode of “I Didn’t Know I Was Pregnant”?
Melvira: Yeah, I mean one of the best parts of the movie was the crying baby drowning baby doll shit. That was creepy. But, it is seriously like they gave up with the plot.
Scara: I know. It could have gone a million places from the point where everyone found out she was pregnant. But instead we got the lamest excuse for an ending. Also, how pregnant was she supposed to be? For the sake of realism they might have wanted to get an OBGYN on set because that Sour Patch baby looked pretty big.
Melvira: Yep. It kinda felt like they got nervous at a point on how to end it,and just reached into the horror bag o’ tricks and were like fuck it, secret cult/satanic baby. Done and done. I would have really liked to see another possession thrown in there, following them from the house, they get back to a slaughter fest at the house. I think i wrote in my notes, “Random horror cliche’s get thicker than Patrick Fabian’s faux southern accent.”
Um … When Did We Start Watching “Hot Fuzz”?
Scara: Then there was the velvet robe/cos-play aspect of it and the decline into total “Blair Witch” ending. Do you think they just wanted to include as many horror cliches as they could think of?
Melvira: Yep. The “Blair Witch” ending was the single most depressing part of that film. I think that they got to a point where they were stuck and if they put everything in there it was bound to appeal to someone.
Scara: Wait! We didn’t even talk about the (literal) writing on the wall. I tend to embrace a use of pentagrams …
Melvira: I mean, when dealing with demons, there is nothing wrong with a little demon graffiti. I’m for it – pro bloody pentagrams. I do love metal though …
Scara: I know. It usually just feels so right. However … In this case, it was just too much.
Melvira: Do you feel like it was the gateway drug to the secret cult? Also, whose blood was that? No one was dead.
Finally – A Message for the Camera Man
Scara: Sigh… Finally, what about the fire? Do you think we’ll be seeing a “No Really, This is the Last Exorcism, We Mean It This Time” in the future?
Melvira: Dude, by the time the fire was there I already checked out. The cgi fire was effing lame. Lame town.
Scara: Yeah it was very “Potter.” I thought Sirius Black was going to start talking to me. Anything else or have we thoroughly picked this apart? You want to send a message to the wise-cracking camera man?
Melvira: Well, being an ultimate fan of bad 80’s horror that guy is essential to the movie. Every horror movie is in need of the guy who is the “fuck that” kinda dude. The one that would keep them all from dying but always gets killed. I love that guy. I’m just sad that he went the way of “The Blair Witch Project.” Sadly, almost frame for frame the same way.
Scara: Yep. Also, if someone goes to the trouble of making a really lovely portrait of you without a head … Just run.