The Friend Zone: The Next Generation
Posted by Maedusa West on Thursday Aug 12, 2010 Under Romance, Sci FiPreviously, Ghouls On Film explored the unfortunate case of Dr. Julia Hoffman, the lovelorn psychiatrist and blood disorder specialist from‘70s gothic soap opera, “Dark Shadows.” She was television and horror’s first female who bore the double-edged burden of being a human woman in love with a vampire (suck on that, Bella Swan!) and being in love with a vampire who passed her over for every fresh-faced brunette in town who would sooner dust him than date him.
Despite sticking with her vampire through thick, thin, and infatuation with younger, human ladies, Julia never ran off into the sunset to make undead vampire babies with Barnabas, but there are a number of fictional females who very well could be her “daughters” in spirit. As foremother to the ladies who have long languished in “The Friend Zone,” Dr. Hoffman still had an easier time than her television descendents who seem to be even more unlucky in love.
“Buffy The Vampire Slayer’s” Willow Rosenberg has more in common with Dr. Hoffman than just red hair. For years, computer genius Willow has pined after her fellow Sunnydale geek, Xander Harris who only has eyes for Buffy, and later spoiled socialite, Cordelia Chase. It is only when Willow finally kindles a relationship with reluctant teen wolf, Oz, that Xander decides Willow is worthy of a second glance and finds himself developing feelings for the girl he had banished to The Friend Zone.
Willow fights the urge to hook up with Xander, and stays the course with Oz, who, in turn, helps bring her out of her shell. Willow begins to make the transformation from naïve, awkward teen geek to a powerful witch in her own right.
After Oz cheats on Willow with a homicidal she-werewolf at college, Willow finally finds love again with Tara Maclay, a fellow witch who teams up with Buffy and her gang to fight for the side of good. Again, Willow’s steady romance does not live past a few seasons when Tara accidentally takes a bullet meant for Buffy at the hands of Warren, a twisted scientist/practitioner of magic.
Willow isn’t the only one to suffer an ill-fated romance after being slapped with “Just Friends” status. Superman and his alter-ego Clark Kent may have zipped to a parallel universe a time or two during “Smallville’s” ten-year run, but it’s his long-suffering sidekick, Chloe Sullivan who finds it is much harder to break free from the Friend Zone than from the Phantom Zone.
Throughout their high school years as outcasts and junior journalists, Clark and Chloe have been a tight-knit twosome. Despite the fact that Chloe is one of the few people Clark entrusts with his secret identity, he just doesn’t see her as relationship-material. Like Barnabas Collins, “Smallville’s” Clark Kent has a fondness for nubile brunettes; he spends time vying for the affections of Lana Lang in the earlier part of the series and now sets his x-ray vision on Chloe’s cousin, Lois Lane. (You know where this is headed.)
By contrast to the dark, flowing locks of Clark’s leading ladies, Chloe frequently sports a blonde bob. Although the two girls are friends throughout high school, Lana Lang is a varsity cheerleader while Chloe is the computer wizard with a journalistic flair. With the arrival of Lois Lane on the scene, somehow Chloe’s cousin co-opts her journalistic shtick, scoring a job at the “Daily Planet” despite a lack of any real credentials beyond her much-ballyhooed spunky streak.
Through it all, Chloe still stands stalwart at Clark’s side, feeling the twist of the knife as he canoodles with her cousin. Although in her early 20s, Chloe is already a widow, following the death of one of the few suitors her friend Clark approved of. Beyond that, she’s been shuttled to the Friend Zone in addition to bearing the indignity of Clark Kent applying the Kryptonian cock-block to any other potential romances she may have.
On the surface, Merlotte’s resident micro braid-sporting spitfire, Tara Thornton of “True Blood” doesn’t seem to share a lot in common with Dr. Julia Hoffman. However, she’s yet another unfortunate denizen of The Friend Zone. For years, Tara has pined after Jason Stackhouse, Bon Temps’ village idiot and brother to her best friend, Sookie. If it moves, Jason Stackhouse will hump it … Unless her name happens to be Tara Thornton.
Even worse, Tara seems to be flypaper for freaks, and (like Willow and Chloe before her) destined for star-crossed love affairs. Tara’s one shot at happiness with Benedict “Eggs” Talley — who is brainwashed, along with Tara, into doing the murderous dirty of madcap maenad Maryann Forrester — ends when Jason Stackhouse accidentally shoots and kills Eggs, sending Tara into a downward spiral. Tough break.
This season on “True Blood,” Tara finds herself as the object of a vampire who is determined to make her his bride. Suffice it to say, there’s nothing like being doomed to dead-ed bliss with a guy you don’t particularly like to snap you out of a suicidal funk.
Looks like Tara’s finally got her groove back. Here’s hoping she fares better with future boy toys than she did with Eggs.
Given the misfortune of ladies like Willow, Chloe, and Tara, what does it say when some of the brightest, strongest women in the horror and fantasy genres are either resigned to “Just Friends” status, or even worse, pre-ordained for romances that end in tragedy? Is there a message that’s being subliminally sent that bright, attractive women somehow don’t quite measure up to their less-brainy counterparts? Here’s hoping the years ahead in the genre finally yield an intellectual lady who can “break the curse” that Dr. Julia Hoffman and her ilk had been saddled with — a curse almost as bad as being an undead creature of the night!

